Healey’s gamble: discipline first, hope later
The Chancellor’s conference speech was the clearest statement yet of the Burnham Government’s economic creed. Whether the country buys it depends on the Budget.
John Healey’s first conference speech as Chancellor will be remembered for a phrase, “a new age of industrialisation”, and for a doctrine: fiscal discipline as the precondition of everything else.
“There’s nothing progressive about losing control,” he told the hall. “Because it’s working people who pay for it.” It is a line designed to do two jobs at once: to reassure the markets that Labour has learned the lessons of the Truss era, and to tell the party’s left that restraint is not betrayal but solidarity.
The gamble is in the sequencing. Healey is asking the country to accept discipline now on the promise of hope later, with the Budget he delivers a month from today as the first instalment. The conference speech was heavy on creed and light on detail, which means the Budget must carry the weight the speech declined to lift.
Every chancellor promises discipline. Healey’s trick is to make it sound like the radical option.Peter Mallory
There were shrewd politics in the packaging. The tribute to Rachel Reeves as the first female Chancellor, the invocation of Gordon Brown’s red tie, the miners’ lamp from Cortonwood: each was a signal to a different Labour tribe that the new Chancellor understands the party’s history even as he asks it to trust his judgment.
The attack lines were chosen with equal care. Calling Nigel Farage “Liz Truss with a Bitcoin account” ties Reform’s economic credibility to the most toxic recent memory in British economic management. It is the kind of line that writes its own headlines, which was rather the point.
But speeches do not move inflation, which stands at 3.1 per cent, or cut waiting lists, which stand at 7.33 million treatments. The test of Healey’s doctrine is not whether conference applauded it, they did, but whether the Budget a month from now makes the country feel the breathing space he promised.
For Andy Burnham, watching from the front row of his first conference as Prime Minister, the speech was also a transfer of risk. The Chancellor now owns the economy. If the Budget lands, they share the credit. If it does not, the Prime Minister has a Chancellor to blame, and the Chancellor has nowhere to hide.
None to date. The Journal corrects errors promptly and transparently. Read our corrections policy.