Devolution across the nations
The United Kingdom is governed unevenly, by design. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland make their own laws in their own parliaments, while England has none.
Britain is not governed from one place. The United Kingdom is a union of four nations, and power is shared between Westminster and three devolved legislatures in an arrangement that is deliberate, lopsided and constantly argued about. To understand British politics, you have to understand that asymmetry.
Scotland has the most powerful of the devolved institutions. The Scottish Parliament sits at Holyrood, at the foot of Edinburgh's Royal Mile, and its 129 Members of the Scottish Parliament make laws on devolved matters: areas such as health, education, justice, transport and the environment. Reserved matters, including foreign policy, immigration, defence and the constitution itself, stay with Westminster. The Parliament's business, its committees and its bills are all published by the Parliament itself.
Wales is governed from the Senedd, the Welsh Parliament, in its glass-fronted building at Cardiff Bay. Its 60 Members pass Senedd Acts, the Welsh equivalent of Acts of Parliament. The institution began life as an assembly with limited powers and has grown, through referendums and new legislation, into a parliament with primary lawmaking authority. Its plenary sessions, committees and records are public, in Welsh and English.
Northern Ireland's Assembly sits in the great white bulk of Parliament Buildings at Stormont, outside Belfast. Its 90 Members are elected under a system designed to ensure that power is shared between unionists and nationalists, and its executive can only function with ministers from both traditions. The Assembly is the product of the 1998 Belfast Agreement, and its history since has been one of suspensions and restorations as often as of steady government.
England is the exception that proves the shape of the system: it has no devolved parliament of its own. England is governed directly by the Westminster Parliament, in which English MPs sit alongside MPs from Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. The one devolution England does have is in London, where the Greater London Authority pairs an elected Mayor with the London Assembly, the body that scrutinises the Mayor's decisions, holds hearings and publishes its reports and minutes.
The point to grasp is that devolution is not federalism. In a federation, the division of power is uniform and constitutional; in Britain, it is four different settlements, negotiated at different times, for different reasons, each with its own scope and its own history. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland do not have the same powers, because they were not given them for the same reasons.
The effects are practical, not abstract. Because health and education are devolved, a policy made in Edinburgh need not match the one made in London or Cardiff: prescriptions, tuition and school curricula can all differ across internal borders. Anyone who lives, works or studies in more than one nation of the UK learns this quickly.
Devolution is also unfinished business, and it is argued about constantly. Westminster retains the power to legislate on reserved matters and, in principle, on devolved ones too; the devolved governments guard their competences; and the question of where one ends and the other begins is settled, when it is settled, in courts and in politics rather than in any single tidy document.
For the reader, the practical consequence is simple: British politics has four stages, not one. A story that begins in Westminster may end in Holyrood, Cardiff Bay or Stormont, and the Journal covers all four. The official record of each legislature is the place to start: the Scottish Parliament, the Senedd and the Northern Ireland Assembly all publish their business, their debates and their legislation in full.
The union survives, in part, because it bends. Devolution is the bending: an admission that one parliament, however sovereign, cannot comfortably speak for four nations at once.
None to date. The Journal corrects errors promptly and transparently. Read our corrections policy.
